Friday, 4 May 2007

Internet, Mission and Ecumenism

Internet, Mission and Ecumenism

Rev Dr Joshva Raja

1. Introduction

Being a student of Electronics and of the Theology I have often tried to explore the common ground between the two. In 2001 I organised a conference on the ‘Perceptions of Islam in the Media’ for the mass media practitioners at the United Theological College, Bangalore. Many journalists, reporters, editors and other communication scholars were present and made this programme a successful one. The participants proposed forming a network to bring more awareness of the false perceptions in the media about our friends from different religions. They asked me whether I could create an e-group that would bring them together. This led to ‘interfaith interaction’ a yahoo e-group with twenty members (mainly media personnel) in 2002 January. As we began to engage in this interaction more people expressed their willingness to join the group. Now, we have 200 members from all over the world.

a. Internet and Action

We continued to discuss issues relating to interfaith issues. As we began discussing the issues our vision widened to include all the issues of religious dialogue and human concern. Religious leaders and scholars from all over the world received the email. I wish to give an example of the impact of our e-group on one person’s life. Mr Ian Stillman is a disabled British charity worker who was working in India among the disabled people since 1974. During his stay in India, he was arrested and was given a ten-year sentence in India on charges of possessing 20 Kg cannabis, a charge he refuted. When he was arrested on 24th June 2002 one of our members placed this information in our group asking people to help his release. As the different religious leaders received this mail from around the world some of our members tried their best to get Mr Ian Stillman released. Mainly the Hindu groups such as Rashtria Sweyamsevak Sangh and Visva Hindu Parisad (fundamentalists groups) requested the government to release him. Even church leaders in UK brought the matter to the British Government and kept the public informed about him. Thus with a lot of pressure from all sides Mr Ian Stillman was released on December 7th 2002. By networking people, institutions and churches with the help of the technology of convergence, we can carry out the tasks of Christian mission and ecumenism in the new ways that was not possible before. I have a few more success stories in using technology that brought changes in the life of individuals and communities.

b. Internet and Dialogue

Through this group we have conducted a number of major programmes of dialogue between different religious leaders (for example RSS-Christian dialogue at the UTC on 22nd March 2002). We carried out peace marches in many parts of India and held a few major ecumenical and interreligious discussions between church leaders and other religious groups in August 2003 (after the recent violence in Gujarat – a state in India). I have established a website separately for this group which will slowly be developed[1]. As an individual who still explores the possibility of bringing about changes through information communication technology, I am planning other explorative websites to see how far the Internet can bring about changes in people’s perceptions and attitudes. My exploration of using the Internet for Interfaith has given me an experiential knowledge in this field. I have also worked as a missionary among Tribal communities in Kerala. I will be reflecting on the use of Internet in the area of mission and ecumenism from these two different experiences. While highlighting a few examples I am also conscious of the limitations of the Internet. Now I would like point out the areas of mission and ecumenism in which the Internet can play a major role. Before I identify the role of the Internet in this area, I like to explain the concept of mission and ecumenism from different perspectives.

2. Media, Mission and Ecumenism

a. Instrumental Use

Very often the churches tend to use the media as instruments of communication in order to expand their sphere of influence. It is known as the extension of the pulpit through which the church attempts to reach out to a wider audience through sermons and worship programmes. Such an attitude can be seen in the statements of World Council of Churches Assembly statements as,

“Evangelically, the churches must resist the temptation to use the media in ways which violate people’s dignity and manipulate them, but rather (the church) should proclaim with humility and conviction the truth entrusted to it[2]”

Most of the churches use the internet as an instrument to provide information about their churches and their programs. The underlying belief behind such an understanding of media and mission is that, God is seen as a fixed sender of the gospel message which is reflected in one of their statements as, “God speaks, the church proclaims… In Jesus Christ God revealed himself to man and made communion with him possible…The (this message) must be preached ….to modern man[3].” Since 1983 many theological views as well as the perception of the churches towards the media have undergone changes and so there is a development in thought in terms of communication of the Gospel to others. Nevertheless one cannot see any changes overall in their engagement with the media in general appropriating other concepts of mission.

Critique

In such an instrumental perspective, Christian communication is seen as an equivalent of passing on information about God and Jesus to all people on earth. Having received the message faithfully from God through Jesus the churches are called to send it to all. The media are seen as mere instruments to carry the gospel from the communicator to the audience. This widens the gap between the communicator and the audience and places the communicator in a superior position than to the audience. The cultural aspects of the media and their hermeneutic role have been neglected. The receiving role of the audience is given more importance than other perspectives. The audience plays a major role in the construction of the meanings of the gospel whereas the above view devalues the persons in favour of the message[4]. It emphasises the powerlessness of the receiver. This traditional model of sender-message-receiver dominated in the understanding of the use of the media in mission.

b. Effect-Centred Perspective

The churches and other institutions also express concern over the media’s impact on people and particularly on Christians. The churches tend to address the ethical and social issues raised by the effect of the media on people. In this effect-centred approach the media are seen as very powerful in reaching the masses with their values and even divides people economically. This is reflected in the Canberra Assembly (1991) where it states, “Means of Communication are powerful tools of hidden control…. The truth is not told and we cannot exercise free judgement. The mass media are a means of cultural imperialism”[5]. Even in the Harare Statement media are seen as technological systems that promote consumerist values and widens gap between rich and poor, powerful and powerless[6].

Critique

The effect-centred perspective has a strong assumption that there is a correlation between some social problems and the effect of the media on the audience. This perspective also predicts continuation and changes in the present economic[7], political[8] and cultural[9] systems. By denying access and dividing people into ‘have’s’ and ‘have not’s’ such technology is seen as widening the existing gap between the rich and the poor. Being a critic of this view Hamelink argues that it is not possible to predict the future social impact of any technology and so social choices about the future can be made under conditions of uncertainty[10]. One needs to recognise certain variables that are involved in the interaction between the media and the audience. It means the observations in one context cannot be generalised to all situations. The media alone cannot be blamed for widening the divisions between the poor and the rich or for the increase in violence in a society.

c. Jesus’ Communication

After analysing these perspectives, I would like to highlight the way Jesus communicated to his audience. In order to have a credible and ideal communication, he accepted his listeners ‘as they were’[11]. Communication as a process can occur between two equal beings. He went to the place where they are. He engaged in the listeners’ communication process. That means, most of the times he used parables, stories and other types of communication that are familiar to his hearers which also reflected their contemporary context. At times his communication began by listening to his opponents or his hearers and thereby engaging along with them in their search for meanings of life and of God rather than simply asking them to comply with his own search for meanings of God and of life. Thereby Jesus engaged in the public communication in the way people expected presenting his meanings among a wide range of meanings that were available to his hearers. Jesus used different methods, means and forms of communication in his mission. It is essential to recognise a model that offers such a diverse mission models in Jesus’ teachings and practice.

I would like to start from these principles of Jesus Christ when setting out to do mission and ecumenism in and through the Internet. I would like to ask a few questions such as: what kind of public space or cultural interaction has the Internet created among the Netizens? In what way do people engage in the Internet? what are they searching for? what are the technological facilities that a website or internet offers to people? how can we engage in different forms of mission? how do we provide network link for people and churches? Based on these questions I would like to highlight some ways in which the churches can get involved in mission and ecumenism in and through the Internet.

4. Internet Scenario in India

a. Internet Reality

The number of people using the Internet in India is expected to rise to 23 million by 2003. At present, it is estimated that about four million people use the Internet in India[12]. There is a large number (more than ten million) of temporary internet users in the cafes which is often not counted. At the same time India’s 2 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) comes through the IT Software and Services Industry in India[13]. When I came to Bangalore in March 2000 there was only one Internet café near UTC whereas now there are no fewer than six Internet Surfing Centres around UTC. In my experience in many of India’s semi-urban cities people know more about fibre optics than underground drainage.

The price of computers is cheaper than some of the household equipment such as a washing machine. From 2,000 knowledge IT workers in 1986, the number increased to 222,090 internet professionals in early 2002[14]. There are 18 Software Technology Parks in India. Bangalore is supposed to be the silicon valley of India. National Informatics Centre (NIC) provides computer support to governments both at central and at state level, thereby networking the government offices and improving the services to the people[15]. To some extent Computerisation of the government work has enabled the officers to reduce the bureaucracy and bribing practices. Nevertheless the majority of the billion people in India does not have access to the Internet and cannot afford to have a computer for a few decades to come. Only a small percentage of the Indian population uses the internet and this is mainly urban based. The divisions between the rich and the poor and between urban and rural are explicit in India. One third of Indian people are below the poverty line. To some extent one can argue that this technology has widened the gap between the ‘information rich and information poor’ in a developing nation like India. Because of these factors there is a dilemma for anyone who intends to attempt to use Internet for mission. Some NGOs explore the possibilities of using the Information Communication Technology (ICT) for the development of the people[16]. The number of users in India is increasing at enormous speed, but accessibility, affordability and availability of the technology to all is still a long way from becoming reality.

Most of our Christian schools provide computer training for their pupils. Access to the Internet in a city is faster and cheaper than in a village, though the government is trying to ensure that villages also get access at the same speed and cost. Some of the urban churches are using computers for different purposes in their ministry. The question of doing mission and ecumenism via the Internet in India needs to be seen from a different perspective as compared to some of the developed countries. My question remains - to what extent can the Internet be useful to the churches in doing mission? While recognising these issues we also need identify the fact that our use of the Internet for mission and ecumenism does not require all the people to have personal access to the Internet. This is where the technology of convergence, connectivity and networking can make the Internet accessible for whole groups of people both within and outside the churches.

c. Internet in Church

There are a variety of ways that the churches in India use the Internet for their mission and ministry. The Churches in India basically provide a website which gives basic information about their institutions, doctrines and activities[17]. Many of them have their own websites[18].

The churches use the website as a means to inform the public. One needs to appreciate some of the churches who are developing these websites and exploring new ways of communicating to the people within and outside the church. As Christians we need to communicate the gospel through all means without hurting or competing with other religious followers. We need to provide certain information such as that we are not forcefully converting any other religious followers using money or any other inducements? This is the first step in our mission which is providing proper information about Christians and the churches to the public through the internet. Majority of the rural churches and dioceses do not have a website and do not have access to internet as well.

d. Netizens and Missionary Organisations

We need to identify the kind of information that is being sought by people on the internet. It means that our website should be open for people to add their suggestions. It should provide a space for people to ask questions, and indicate how and where the netizens can meet up with the churches. Some of the missionary organisations[19] and individuals provide information and publicity about their activities in order to raise support for them[20]. They do not create any space for interaction for the people in the internet. Some of them have even developed online donation forms[21]. There are not many websites that present the gospel in the people’s own languages (regional languages) and also in an interactive way. This is one of the major tasks facing the churches today; to make the gospel message accessible to local people in their own language. Email is a very good way to reach people who, for a number of reasons, may be living away from home - enabling them to form a virtual community.

e. Christian Institutions

Theological seminaries also have their own websites, as do missionary organisations and other Christian institutions[22]. They provide basic information about their institutions and courses that they offer[23]. I have begun to see that the institutions are not in a position to provide an interactive website because of their effect-centred approaches. Many of them are told that the Internet is part of globalisation and will widen the gap between the rich and the poor. They fear that some of the information available will destroy the values of the society, and that children, and other vulnerable people, might have access to pornography or other undesirable material. Some of this could be true, but not all use the Internet for these purposes. Even those who are against this technology in public use it when it becomes essential for them. Such views have made the Christian institutions sceptical about the use of technology. Also, an unwarranted fear is being created by a few, who do not know the technology or of ways to protect the system, that people can intrude into their computer using their websites and infect their computers with viruses. Frequently, institutions have no clear idea about the copyright of documents and files, and this creates more uncertainty and confusion in providing online archives and libraries to the public.

A few years ago one of our visiting professors, Prof. Fore started a website – Religion Online. He asked me whether I could help him in collecting files which I did for him[24]. The purpose was to provide a number of books and articles on the website for the sake of the students, and other researchers from the developing nations, who cannot afford to buy the expensive books from the West. Today it is one of the top most visited websites in the area of religion.

Some individuals use websites for different purposes which are often ecumenical and dialogical, though limited in service, and not representative of their churches’ or institutions’ views. Some are doing mission in the sense of social networking: development, oriented websites and religious dialogue programmes which are helpful to communities at large[25]. Among them only a few are aware of the advanced technological capabilities, and culture of interaction and communication which is rapidly developing through the internet. This knowledge would have enabled them to be more interactive, effective and participatory in their mission.

f. Yahoo groups

Besides an e-group for the interfaith dialogue, I maintain a network of NGOs who are working among Refugees and a group for the communication scholars at South Asian level to share our theories and concepts. A few others have email lists for other interested groups and members. These groups are seen as interactive groups where people express their views freely. Through our efforts we have created our own space for communication. At times through these networks we, the members, feel that we are doing something for the development of others such as refugees and poor people. Recently we have started an e-group for the pastors who are interested in HIV/AIDs awareness and for theologians who are interested in ecological issues. The messages are made available for anyone to have access.

Even though these e-groups help us to organise major conferences, seminars, dialogue and other projects, I do not receive any financial support to run these groups. Some of the international organisations have asked me whether they could run similar e-groups. I have given them guidance regarding these groups. The Government of India has blocked some of e-groups and so I have started constructing websites for these e-groups. My e-groups on interfaith interaction is under construction and the address is www.interfaithinteraction.org. We plan to have an interactive page on this website, as the e-groups were blocked only recently after a major International conference in Bangalore in August 2003. The problem with all the above methods is that we have not yet explored the other ways of doing mission. There are other e-groups who network Christians, Churches and NGOs from all over the world. We need to network those who are engaged in this networking ministry[26]. Those who are interested in doing mission have not come to grasp the culture of the internet. We are accustomed to send and receive mail by air or sea which takes days and at times months.

5. Cultural Characteristics of the Internet

The technology of the internet has introduced a new culture – a culture of communicating at high speed, a culture of interactivity and a culture of hypertexts, a culture of ‘wandering self’, and a new religious culture. It is a mediated communication – which one can identify as e-communication or Web Mediated Communication (WMC). Those who engage in such communication have allowed themselves to be influenced by the culture of internet. At first the WMC influences people’s perceptions, attitude, faith and worldview and enables each person to discover one’s self in one’s own way. Secondly it makes an impact on the relationship between persons – at interpersonal level and enhances the relationship to grow at the speed of the light or break it at the same speed. Through such interpersonal relationship people discover a virtual friendship, relationship and also communities with which they can affiliate themselves. Thirdly WMC influences the social, economical, political status of the people. The following section will highlight a few issues in the culture of Internet which needs to be recognised before we consider some of the efforts of mission and ecumenism in and through the Internet.

In the culture of interaction people began to look at the way the religion itself begin to change. People from different religious communities use internet for different purposes. Their religious faith is also being influenced by the Internet. Fabio Pasqualetti[27] argues that the new Internet culture is challenging the global and local discrimination of the people. It has moved the users from their institutional affiliation of a religion to seekers of personal spirituality. The Internet users changed their affiliation from believing traditions to affiliation of meanings. They are seekers of subjective truth rather than objective truth. Their language is of a cultural language rather than of a technocratic language. Thus internet users form their own relationship with others. They search for God and for meanings in their own way. God is the one of the most popular searched subject of the Internet[28]. The culture that has emerged in the internet is a complex as well as post modern type of culture.

a. High Speed and exchange of information

In the interaction between human beings and the Internet we need to identify the way the new technology differs from the old media technology. People often emphasise the high speed with which they can access enormous quantities of information. With telephone facilities we speak with other person or send faxes, which depend on the availability of the other person. But here we can send any texts with nearly the speed of the light to the other person. We write and receive the reply at high speed. It brings people closer in terms of sharing information, resources and opinions. Through email and e-groups people interact with each other at a great speed (chat mails are banned in some countries). At times major decisions are taken and many programmes are broadcast using fast interactive services. The communicators feel the presence of the other in the internet, but virtually. Using the File Transfer Protocol, one can change any text of their website at any place of the world if one has the username and password of the site. I can also have access to my e-group from any part of the world and moderate the discussions.

b. Interactive Internet

Mail can be sent in seconds from one part of the world to another. It will include material of all kinds: information, pictures, educational material, entertainment programmes, knowledge banks, along with junk mail. It is proving difficult to screen or control unwanted or unsolicited information. One can ‘post’ useful information on the websites. Instantaneously one can have access to any government or non-government website and send mail to ministers about any issue. Because both the communicator and receiver can play an alternative role of sending and receiving, a new culture has evolved in the use of Internet which is interactive in its nature. In such an interactive culture the gap between sender and receiver is reduced[29]. In this interactive culture there is a high speed sending, sharing, and transfer of information and data to each other. This interactivity encourages people to participate and to interact with each other in an easy manner and enables them to establish a new democratic and equal relationship[30].

c. Convergence and hypertext

The digital convergent technology brings together many other analogical media operations into a digital language and is enabled, thereby, to converge the applications. For example this digital technology is useful in bringing together audio-visual, written and 3-D texts and in linking up the operations of a radio, video and short message service. Digital Technology is able to transcend some of the limitations of previous technologies. “In cyberspace we can construct worlds that have no connection with physical reality[31]”. Because of the availability of hypertext the exploration is made possible according to one’s own interest. Communication is not simply making sense but being there to recognise and accept the other being present in the internet. In the internet culture there is a choice for the users to continue to search as they wish through hypertexts. There is no ‘start’ and ‘end’ point in one’s search. The person becomes a ‘wandering self’ in the wilderness of information.

d. Digital world and Virtual Self

The Internet provides a self-identity for many users. It helps the individuals to form their real and virtual self with an interaction through and with the internet. The Internet provides a multiplicity of the self – by projecting oneself into a internet and seeing a self without reflecting the self itself[32]. At times there is a gap between the projected self and the real self - highlighting the diversity of the character of the person. The Internet not only provides a space for social relations to occur, but provides the tools needed to enter that space. The internet creates a desire for more interaction and information about anything and everything - virtual community and virtual presence. Digital technology removes us from the physical experience of the other and from contact with the physical reality. There is an absence of physical language[33]. On the internet, one surfs. This passage from one point to the other on the internet is reflected sometimes, in this style of life, as the passage from one experience to another, but in its more positive and mature form it is experienced as a culture of separation, of non-affiliation to something specific. It favours the spirit of search. It is a culture that offers and is generous, although it can also be a place of abuse and embezzlement[34].

The user often tends to float the ‘self’ with strange identities and establish relationship within what he or she has created about her –self or him-self. Elizabeth M. Reid describes “the formation of a new society out of Internet Relay Chat (IRC)”[35]. The users of IRC choose to join a channel and select a ‘nickname’ under which to interact. The users have created a whole set of written symbols that enable them to express feelings in a written form. The widespread use of ‘Emoticons’ is strong indication of the important role affections have on the Internet. Users of IRC often develop strong friendships with a sense of responsibility to their fellows, and regard their electronic world with a great deal of seriousness. By detaching the virtual self from the real self often the user finds it to communicate the way he wanted to. With the use of nickname, Emoticons and non-affliation there is a communication without transfer of any meanings from one person to the other but the presence of both in the internet is what matters.

e. God and I in the Internet

There is also a need to recognise the individuals’ and communities’ search for meanings of life and of God in the internet. The second most subject searched in the internet is God. There is a kind of spirituality in the Internet in which the netizen wishes to search for meanings of God and of life in their own ways. They search for recognition of the people and those who engage with them in their search, at times in a funny way, at times in a serious manner and at times in a manipulative manner. They allow their ‘I’s to be floated. An affiliation to a free Hotmail/Yahoo email service means to have an access to the Internet address from any part of the world. Others send their mails to this box even if I am not there. I can have access to this site from any part of the world. It seems like a wandering self which immediately changes into another self or disappears in the internet. Even the communities are engaged in search for meanings of life and of God. We need to recognise and engage in this search for meanings, providing our own meanings without condemning other meanings that are available to them.

f. The Other side of the Internet

In this culture there is also a problem of spreading a virtual hatred about other religious or minority communities. In this interactive culture such ‘hate’ texts should be identified and raised with the people concerned – moderators, hosts, or countries - so that such texts will no longer be available to the public. Online pornography is one of the major problems and most of the internet-café users misuse the internet for this purpose. This has evolved into a culture of viewing porns, and both parents and teachers need to instruct the children to avoid it. The intruders are often big problems in many of our internets[36]. While recognising the positive elements of the Internet culture we need to identify the way the digital divide is made between the rich and the poor. The discrimination is not explicit in the internet but the access is easier to an urbanised middle class youth than a rural poor person. I find it difficult to argue against the fact that technology has widened the division between rich and poor. Yet, while recognising this critically I find that there is a possibility of engaging in a positive way, in mission and ecumenical activities through the Internet.

6. Internet and Mission - Possibilities

There are various ways with which the churches can engage in the Internet culture. In this context they can consider engaging with the innovative technological means, the interactive way of communication and the virtual communities. The mainline church institutions should find ways of providing a internet server in order to host some of their websites by themselves. For this they need the Public Internet Protocol- PIP address. They also need to participate e-groups, e-communities, and online newspapers/newsletters, email connections, Development oriented, liberative, advocacy related and Interactive sites. This would enhance on the one hand the ongoing communication process within the churches and between the churches and those who are outside the churches and also on the other hand the public communication in which other religious communities are also involved. In this section I am highlighting certain possibilities of taking part in the culture of internet and discover new ways of doing mission and ecumenism.

a. Sharing the Gospel

The charismatic and evangelical groups have recognised the potential power of the internet and have already started placing their video on demand, their sermons (both text and audio files) besides providing any other information that the users want. Some of these groups provide misinformation about Christians and Christianity by emphasising the number of converts through their mission, by popularising the prosperity gospel and by highlighting their links to certain fundamentalist Christians in other parts of the world[37]. This creates a bad image for Christianity, and Christians, and is one of the main reasons for attacks on churches. Our first task of mission is to provide moderate information about the gospel to all people through the internet. We need to make our doctrines, tradition and gospel clear to the internet users. As I mentioned already the National Council of Churches or the main church offices can provide a Internet Server which can host member churches’ websites for a low cost. Each member church can be encouraged to communicate the gospel in the way they wanted to. Such an attempt will both be evangelical as well as ecumenical in its praxis. It is essential to encourage churches to develop websites in the regional languages rather than in English.

b. Interactive Communities

The digital technology, culture, space and virtual communities of the Internet provide a platform for us, and also many challenges for our mission. There are diverse ways of doing mission in and through the Internet. One of the best ways is to engage with individuals who are seeking meanings of the gospel through the internet. Through e-groups, e-communities and websites we can establish contact with those who searching for the meanings of the gospel. At times we have to establish groups for Christians and non-Christians and be ready to respond to individual questions from both groups. The kind of pseudo-identity of the participants helps people to ask genuine questions and try to find answers from others in the groups. The content of the discussion will differ according to individual or community interest. These discussions can be widened to search for meanings of life and of religions. We can also establish different groups or communities in order to differentiate discussions on different topics. We have expertise in areas such as counselling, ministerial guidance, lay training, and mission studies. With their help we may be able to provide online counselling or answer theological questions or clarify some questions about Christianity itself. For example ask any questions related to a group named “God and theology” through which we can have discussions.

In my experience of certain e-communities, I realised that the participants in the discussions are not interested in finding out facts about God, or objective information about someone’s faith, but in listening to stories – stories of life and stories of faith. Many non-Christians who want to know about Christianity and the gospel should be informed. Even if they do not want to change their religion we can continue engage with such individuals or communities. We also can establish e-groups and email lists which are very helpful in terms of networking people. The kind of pseudo-identity of the participants helps people to ask genuine questions and try to find answers from others in the groups. The content of the discussion will differ according to the individual or community’s interest. These discussions can be widened to search for meanings of life and of religions. We can also establish different groups or communities in order to differentiate discussions on different topics. To engage in this way we need a website, and text box using CGI (Common Gateway Interface -Linux)/ASP (Active Server Pages -Windows). Our website will be interactive if we use the blogging method to collect information from different parts of the world immediately[38]. Our website can host all the unedited and unrestricted information about the churches with ‘no-offence’ policy.

c. Serving Christian Community

The churches can cater for their members’ needs by conducting online worship, by holding discussion groups, by providing information about their members in the website, by placing their liturgies, sermons and devotional material for others to read. Today the segmentation of individuals and communities is increasingly becoming a reality in which the church can play a role in bringing people together virtually and thus establish a virtual Kingdom of God. We also need to place Christian educational material in our website so that it can be useful for others. For those who cannot come to the church the virtual online worship might enable them to worship along with others, even though virtual worship does not replace real worship. Our mission is to bring separated people together in order to establish a community of God where broken relationships are restored and communities reconciled. Of course we can make use of the modern technology of convergence such as video on demand or online radio that cost less than analogical broadcasting or even the narrowcasting. New liturgies, attractive sermons and new songs can be placed on the churches’ website so that others can use them. Many children are taught to use computers in their schools. When they come back they try to play with the computers, we can also produce interactive animated Bible stories and value oriented songs and stories and place them in our websites. As most of these are available in English we need to consider producing in one’s own regional language.

d. Training Pastors and Missionaries

We need to train mission workers, pastors and theologians to use the Internet as an interactive tool for communication. Our approach to mission in using the Internet should not divide us; rather we need to be in a position to accept other types of mission and evangelism along with our present efforts to carry out God’s work. These tasks require both the expertise of software engineers, and experience in the field of mission, leading to an inclusive strategy of mission and knowledge of using the internet. For this we need to train the ministerial candidates and theological students to have knowledge of internet publishing and hosting. At the United Theological College we offer the courses (Word - Desk Top Publishing – Web designing) to our students so that they might use them in their ministry and mission. We would like the seminaries to encourage the pastors to continue their education using Distance Online Learning (DOL) which is used by many universities to promote their higher education for those who are in jobs. It is also essential for the pastors to become aware of certain issues and methods of communication in the Internet.

It is essential to promote Internet-Literacy which means to make the internet-users critical readers (literate) of the internet. The problem of pornography should be addressed at all levels from the government, NGOs, churches and parents. In order to enable the children to use the internet properly the churches need to provide interesting, creative and imaginative websites. The websites should be interactive and open ended to ask any question to anyone, and the content should be edutainment and infotainment oriented so that the young people, and others, will visit and use our websites. If such is the case we will certainly be able to transcend our doctrinal, denominational, religious and national boundaries and do a holistic mission and ecumenism in the internet. Training pastors and missionaries online is a good attempt. With the help of Senate of Serampore we are planning to provide an interactive learning for the D Min distance education students. Such attempts are already made in India by the Secular universities.

e. Ecumenical Internet

It is essential to engage in the Internet is to network people, organisations and churches who share different interests. Ecunet[39] is an example which brings together the churches ecumenically. Our Mission is to network and serve churches and also to initiate an ecumenical dialogue among the churches. In urban areas the networking of the church members is also possible. Lists of the members may be drawn up. Such attempts can help a lot in terms of ministry. Establishing the churches’ websites will also help them to provide information about the churches, membership and the activities. They can be identified as credible centres for information. Many ecumenical issues can be discussed and an ecumenical union might happen first at virtual level, and then in reality. This could also help us to transcend our borders and establish relationship with each other. One of the major questions that is being asked today is why the churches in the west are losing their members whereas the churches in India and other developing countries are growing in numbers. I would suggest that congregation-to-congregation networking and pastor-to-pastor networking could be done. Even online video conferencing facilities are possible to make congregations to speak to each other in any language with a proper translator. Networking can also help the churches to work together in the Internet and to learn from each other the way to do mission. Even constructing a website together with another church needs courage and a radical step. When the internet helps people to break their barriers of language and border, then it can also help to eliminate the denominational barriers and other types of blocks that would hinder us from coming closer to one another.

f. Networking different Communities

Networking can go beyond the process of bringing together the churches of different traditions; it can also attempt to bring together different religious communities. The internet provides a platform, and also the space, for people of different faiths to express themselves openly in a way which might not be possible otherwise. In certain contexts people of different faiths cannot come together because of their doctrinal or ideological affiliations. Seeing a leader making a statement publicly about religious dialogue can be misinterpreted or misunderstood by followers of the same tradition; whereas the interactive nature of the internet allows concepts to be freely expressed. The networking of NGOs will certainly help in the sharing of experiences, or best practice, from one area to another. When I do refugee networking the information is very important because next day it becomes part of a published newsletter for many NGOs who are working among the refugees. As this message is spread to the top-level leaders some kind of action is taken either in its favour or against. Recently we ended up pressurising the Indian government to talk to the Bhutan government regarding the return of their Nepali Refugees. Networking Christian NGOs is important because many of them do not know what others are doing and repeat the same development programmes, which is a waste of resources. Mission is more effective if ideas and resources can be shared. Through networking, and information sharing, the sponsoring agencies would know what progress NGOs are making and of any problems to be addressed.

g. Banking the Knowledge

Another way of engaging in mission is to provide space for knowledge banks where archives, hypertexts of information sources, and research materials in any language are made available. For example, in many of our seminaries the documents are decaying with time. Some of them are made into microfiche whereas other books or material cannot be opened because of their deteriorating condition. The archives in Pope’s college Sawyerpuram contain all the G U Pope’s writings. He was the first missionary to translate Hindu Texts into a foreign language. Such material can be copied, with the help of a scanner or digital camera, and can be preserved using Word or Acrobat (PDF) or zip files. These can be compressed in such a way that even a compact disc (CD) can contain the whole library archives. If all the archive material in India can be made into CDs, the books can be preserved and also copyright can be sold to different universities around the world. Even the theses of the Senate of Serampore College can be made into a CD so that this could be available for others who are doing research in related areas.

A large volume of knowledge is preserved in text form in India. Unfortunately our systems in India have not come to understand the way to preserve this knowledge and share it with others. Some are considering this work which of course involves an investment. In our library we are trying to provide our catalogue online so that people across the world can have access to our library. It would be good if the theological libraries and colleges can be networked together sharing similar information[40]. The Internet helps one to create a knowledge bank. Preservation and sharing of the knowledge bank for their own income also becomes an attractive possibility. There is a need to protect certain cultural traditions of the people such as oral and written history and medical knowledge. The internet can be a channel of preserving such traditions. Thus the voice of the voiceless – not often heard in the mainstream media - can be projected to the outside world.

h. Preserving the traditions and culture

I would like to highlight the fact that not only texts but also audio and visual material can be preserved through such technology and made available to people. Some people have lost their identities because they have lost their history. It is often argued that some people’s history was intentionally eliminated by destroying their written historical documents and by taking away their traditions. The remaining element is the oral culture of a people. This, too, can be preserved through the internet and be made available on the websites. In many places the Backward, Dalit and Tribal Communities have oral traditions – stories, songs and music. Of course some of them are recorded on audio cassettes. These can be preserved and shared by making them available to other people. The way some of the communities solve their own problems can also be narrated and recorded in the internet. Particularly the traditional medical, agricultural knowledge, information about animals and other traditional wisdom can be brought together and preserved without exploiting the people. This knowledge could be sold and the income shared with the people who provided such wisdom to others. In this way our mission will be genuine in the sense that we are engaged in the liberative process of the people. The process of development is also enhanced due to the enormous quantity of information that is available in the internet, exposure of the authentic issues to the public, people’s participation in their own developmental process and a liberative experience in accessing the internet.

i. Internet as Alternative Media

Internet can also play a role of alternative media and so an alternative mission. It is an alternative because some of the news or information through other media can be censored or blocked by the government or powerful people whereas in the internet it is not possible. At times the incidents in Tiananmen Square were informed to the outside world first through the internet. Then photos were sent to the media via emails and websites. It is essential to expose at times certain events and incidents which otherwise do go unreported. Particularly persecution of Christians in Pakistan[41], of Muslims in Gujarat and of democratic forces in Burma are a few examples which cannot be reported through a main stream media. Internet is the best source to report these problems to the world. At times it is also essential to expose certain practices such as double cup (discrimination of Dalits, Backward castes and others) in teashops of South India, hunger deaths of Adhivasis in Orissa and secret deaths of Tribal community members in North East India. Only by networking people, churches and NGOs we can inform such incident to the outside world authentically. Exposing poverty itself is part of mission as Indian government claims to become self-reliant in food production where as people do not get one time food grains from public distribution system (PDS). Such activities are to be seen as part of mission.

7. Conclusion

I would like to conclude by saying that we need to have a holistic understanding of mission where the tension between diverse views can be held together. Unless we try to challenge the theology of mission the churches may not be able to interact with the Netizens and their culture. The churches should also be encouraged to recognise the importance of using the Internet in their mission and ministry. Whatever criticism that we have about the information communication technology, the Internet has come to stay here. It have made an impact on the users at intra-personal, interpersonal, group and mass communication level and has created a culture of fast and interactive communication. A considerable number of people are engaged in such communication where we need a new strategy of mission which I call ‘plurality of mission’. In such perspective a holistic understanding of mission emerges without removing the old. Such understanding of mission seems to recognise the tension between different perspectives on mission. It becomes essential for me to bring the tension in the understanding of mission while considering the Internet. I find out that there are many opportunities for using the Internet. Through the internet we may be able to share the gospel, liberate people, bring about awareness, develop and build communities and show the care for all. The convergent technology of the internet helps to explore new possibilities in this area such as audio-video conferencing. The above-suggested methods are not very expensive rather they could be maintained at a normal local price. At times to establish website the churches need some of the software for these programmes and texts.

The churches should also consider going beyond the way they communicate among themselves and with others. The interactive culture of the internet challenges the churches’ existing practices of communication. ‘Being there’ is what makes the internet users comfortable with the church. The churches are called to participate, interact and bring about awareness about different social issues. The churches’ presence and her listening is what going to do much in mission and ecumenism. When I started constructing websites, using e-groups and participating in ongoing discussions, I realised the fact there is a God’s presence in the Internet and try to engage with other communities and believers in their search for meanings of God and life. Ian Stillman’s release may be an example of what had happened through the internet. If we try to follow one of the above models we might be able to carry out the tasks of mission with a spirit of ecumenism. By engaging creatively with the Internet culture the churches and Christian institutions can change the society and bear witness to God’s mission in the world.



[2] D.Gill 1983, Gathered for Life: Official Report IV Assembly WCC, Geneva: WCC. P.107.

[3] Goodall, N 1968. The Uppsala Report 1968: Official Report of the Fourth Assembly of the World Council of Churches. Geneva: WCC. pp.394-5

[4] D C Weber, ‘Sharing the Word: A Theology of Communication’, Ministerial Formation. July 58, pp.21-23. 1992.

[5] M Kinnamon (ed) 1991, Sings of the Spirit: World Council of Churches Official Report, Seventh Assembly, Canberra: WC, p.83].

[6] Eighth Aseembly of the WCC, Harare, 1999, www.wcccoe.org/wcc/assembly/index WCC Web 1999:25.

[7] A perpetuation of the capitalist mode of production, with a further refinement of managerial control over the production processes which results massive job displacement and de-skilling.

[8] A pseudo-democracy will emerge, allowing people to participate in marginal decisions only. ICTs will enable to exercise surveillance over their citizens more effectively than before. The proliferation of ICTs in the home will individualise information consumption to a degree that makes the formation of a democratic, public opinion no more than an illusion.

[9] There are tendencies of forceful cultural “globalization” - e.g. Macdonaldization and aggressive cultural tribalization - fragmentation of cultural communities into fundamentalist cells with little or no understanding of different tribes.

[10] Cees Hamelink, “ICTs AND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT: THE GLOBAL POLICY CONTEXT”, Papers presented at the UNRISD Conference on Information Technologies and Social Development. Geneva, 22-23 June 1998, http://www.unrisd.org/infotech/conferen/icts/toc.htm. P.6

[11] I have highlighted these principles of Jesus’ communication in my book, ‘Facing the Reality of Communication: Culture, Church and Communication’. New Delhi: ISPCK, 2001.

[12] BBC News South Asia India internet users set to soar… http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/848832.stm

[13] Research, Reference and Training Division ed, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, India, ‘Information Technology’ 2002, New Delhi: Quick Printers, p.160,

[14] http://stylusinc.com/internet_potential_india.htm

Internet Potential in India - Sharon Colaco - India's Webspertise

[15] Research, Reference and Training Division ed, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, India, ‘Information Technology’ 2002, New Delhi: Quick Printers, p.165,

[16] M S Swaminathan project which attempts to provide useful information to fisher communities.

http://poverty.worldbank.org/files/14654_MSSRF-web.pdf

http://www.mssrf.res.in/

Voices,a Bangalore based organisation is trying to help disabled children to use computers.

[17] The Church of South India provides basic information about the churches and their activities. http://www.csisynod.org/

In the same way the United Evangelical Churches in India too provide a good website with a lot of information about their activities.

http://www.uelcindia.org/index.html

To see a specific diocese please visit http://www.csitirunelveli.org/csi_td.asp

[18] The following sites provide best examples for the above argument.

The Church of South India’s website - http://www.cnisynod.org/

National Council of Churches in India - http://www.nccindia.org/

Othodox Churches - http://www.otsindia.org

The United Evangelical Lutheran Church - http://www.uelci.org/

Marthoma Church http://www.marthomachurch.com/Heritage-Mission/15thcentury-story.htm

The Assemblies of God church - http://business.vsnl.com/zion/

Indian Pentecostal church - http://www.angelfire.com/al3/ipcpallipad/ipc.html

Independent Baptist Churches’ directory - http://www.baptistinfo.com/States/INDIA/INDIA.HTM

[19] There are number of missionary organisations that send missionaries but do have websites - Diocesan Missionary Band -http://www.dmpb.org/

Radio Viswavani - www.vishwavani.org & http://www.gospelcom.net/twr/

Voice of Hope - http://www.radiovoiceofhope.net/

Adventist Radio asia - http://www.awr.org/awr-asia/

Other organisations are Friends Missionary Prayer Band, Indian Missionary Society, National Missionary Society, GEMS, Indian Church Growth Mission (an Indigenous one)

[25] http://www.cmai.org/memb-mp.htm

This is a website of Christian Medical Association of India. This website has lots of information about medical work in India. More people from abroad would have visited this page than many Indians.

http://www.hmiindia.com/academic_04.htm

This is the website of Henry Martin Institute which also provides information about their programmes and activities.

[26] Some examples of other groups can be seen in these websites which are mainly for Indian Christians http://asiapacificuniverse.com/asia_pacific/messages30/358.html

http://www.ayrookuzhiyil.bravepages.com/links.html

[27] Fabio Pasqualetti, Characteristics of Digital Culture - A Challenge For Education http://www.jmcommunications.com/english/DigitalCulture.html

[28] The search engine Google has 32,500,000 sites talking about God.

[29] This new technology is directing communities towards a new type of society where they become principle organisers. The Multi-User Dungeons (MUDs) provide unlimited access to anything on the Internet – converging the texts into audio-visual-written- graphic multimedia texts. There is an open access to anyone to create his or her own website. Information is fragmented

Heather Campbell, Cultural Implications of the Internet & Postmodernity, pp39-47, in Interactions: Theology Meets Film,TV and the Internet. Edited by Heidi Campbell and Jolyon Mitchell Edinburgh: CTPI, 1999.

[30] Stanely Hauerwas, A Community of Character, (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame, 1981), 44.

[31] David Lochhead, Shifting Realities: Information Technology and the Church. Geneva: WCC, 1997, p.68.

[32] Turkle,S. Life on the Screen: Identity in the Age of the Internet, London: Phoenix-Orion Books,Ltd 1997.

[33] David Lochhead, Shifting Realities: Information Technology and the Church. Geneva: WCC, 1997.

[34] Jones, S ed Cybersociety, London: Sage 1995.

[35] Reid, Electropolis: Communication and Community on the Internet Relay Chat, 1991. For more valuable reading on cultural issues in cyberspace, see Elizabeth M. Reid, Cultural Formations in Text-Based Virtual Realities, M.A. Thesis at University of Melbourne, Australia, Department of History, 1994. Available from http://www.ee.mu.oz.au/papers/emr/cv.html

[36] David Lochhead, Shifting Realities: Information Technology and the Church. Geneva: WCC, 1997.

[37] One of the examples is Jesus’ Calls ministries where you find a kind of tele-evangelism and internet evangelism with much emphasis on prosperity and promises of blessings. http://www.prayertoweronline.org /

[39] Ecumenical Internet can be seen in the website - http://www.ecunet.org/

another ecumenical site - http://home.wizard.org/eocc/eocc1/front.html

[40]We need to follow some of the examples already set before us – such as Reformed Online where virtual library of Reformed Protestantim is made available. Making it free for those who are not able to access this at the cost of those who can access these pages… http://www.reformiert-online.net:8080/t/eng/bibliothek/inedx.jsp.

[41] John Roxborogh Persecution: Interpreting the information on the Internet, Evangelical Review of Theology, 24:1, 31-40, 2000.